Email Marketing for Etsy Sellers (Best Way To Build Customer Loyalty)

Last Updated:

February 25, 2024


Marketing & Promotion
Table Of Content
Growing Your Craft is supported by Etsy sellers. When you purchase/subscribe through affiliate links in this guide, I'll earn some coffee money at no extra cost to you.

Email marketing is an effective way to build up a loyal customer base which will come back again and again in the future.

Many sellers on Etsy don’t take advantage of this. Basically leaving money on the table.

This guide will walk you through exactly how you can set the process up, let it run by itself, and have customers return to your store.

What Is Email Marketing?

Email marketing is a powerful marketing tool that involves sending emails to customers (actual customers and potential customers) with these purposes:

With all the different marketing tactics nowadays, email remains one of the most useful and profitable. Let’s look at why your Etsy shop needs it:

Benefits Of Email Marketing

Targeted Communication To Your Customers

Especially in your case, you know the emails will be sent to customers who are interested in your products. You can target your message to speak directly to them.

High Return To Investment

Litmus says email marketing has a return on investment (ROI) of 38:1, which means for $1 invested, business on average gets $38 back. We will learn how to maximize that.

You Own Your Email List

Even in case that your Etsy shop gets in any trouble, you still own your email subscriber list. Having those contacts could mean make-or-break if you need to start something new.

Are You Allowed To Email Etsy Customers?

Although you are not allowed to add customers' emails directly to your email list (as that would violate Etsy rules and can risk your shop being closed down), you can encourage them to sign up in two main ways - direct messages on Etsy and automatic receipt message in their order receipt.

Creating A Lead Magnet

As a Etsy seller, we can create something valuable that your customers can’t resist, so that they are willing to exchange their email with that valuable thing.

And that thing is called a lead magnet, which is a marketing tool that is used to generate more email subscribers.

This ebook from Growing Your Craft is an example of a lead magnet

Features Of A Good Lead Magnet

We need to think about what your customers actually want, and custom make a lead magnet for them in order to build your subscriber list effectively.

It could be a VIP coupon code that makes them feel special, or a product guide that helps them makes the best use of their purchase. Remember to keep in mind how you can benefit your customers when making the lead magnet.

Sign Up To A Email Marketing Service

The main things to look for in an email marketing service are good functionality, reasonable pricing and good deliverability. I suggest testing out their free trial and see how the interface work and whether it’s easy to use.

Services like ConvertKit and Mailchimp are popular choices for Etsy sellers.

ConvertKit is one of the best email marketing services

Sending Lead Magnet To Customers Who Subscribe

Now that people can sign up to your email list, let’s deliver our promise of the lead magnet to them when they sign up.

In cases like a coupon code, free shipping code, giveaway, or other lead magnets that is text based, you only need to include it in the automatic message to subscribers when they sign up.

But if you have a lead magnet that is a file like in PDF format, then you need to attach it with the automatic message. Most email marketing services let you do that, but if that is not possible, you can attach the file to your Google Drive and send them the download link instead:

  1. On the left, click “New” and “File Upload”
  2. Choose your file to attach
  3. Right click on your file in Google drive and choose “Get Link”
  4. At the bottom of the pop up, change from “restricted” to “Anyone with the link”
  5. Copy the link and paste it in your email message

Writing Email Subject Lines That Customers Will Click

Use Emojis

Emojis are fun and lighthearted. And most importantly, eye-catching. Open your email inbox now and look at all the promotional emails you have. Do the ones with emojis pop out to you?

Use Urgency If Needed

If you run the sale only for 3 days, say it in the subject line “3 Days Left!”, “Ending Soon”. Don’t use it for every email though, you don’t want to be the “seller that cried wolf”.

Keep It Short

Short subject lines are easier to read than long ones. And most shops use long subject lines. Using a short one will make yours pop.

Make It A Question

Sometimes asking a question will make customers more curious and click. “Do you know that this new material is 3 times softer?”, “Fun fact, do you know diamond is the hardest gemstone on Earth?”, etc.

Sending Sales Emails & New Products Emails

Email marketing is a great way to announce new products and promotions to your customers throughout the year. This is especially important during holiday sales periods like Black Friday and Christmas.

When launching new products, create an email that include the followings:

For sales and promotional emails, it's a good idea to emphasise a sense of urgency for the sales. For example, you can put "20% Discount Ending In 3 Days". Also be sure to make it obvious what you want the customers to do and avoid any distractions. If you want them to click the link to your Etsy shop, don't include all your social media links to distract them.

What's Next

To take your email marketing to the next level, check out the in-depth email marketing course inside GYC Etsy Academy 2.0. You'll learn how to create effective campaigns that drive sales and build customer loyalty. Plus, use our email templates to build an automated system that keeps customers coming back. Sign up for GYC Etsy Academy 2.0 today and access Email Marketing For Etsy Sellers

Looking to grow your Etsy shop?
3 Ways GYC Helps You Get More Sales On Etsy
GYC Etsy Academy 2.0 📈
GYC Etsy Academy 2.0 is the complete, battle-tested solution that helps you build and grow your Etsy shop that you’ve always wanted, effortlessly.

Boost your productivity, increase your creative output, and grow your income.
Learn More About GYC Etsy Academy 2.0
Growing Your Craft Etsy Blog
Actionable guides and step-by-step tutorials designed to empower Etsy sellers like you in growing your shop
Read Free Etsy Guides
GYC Branding Templates
Browse professional branding templates for your handmade business, from thank you cards to product labels
GYC Etsy Shop
NEW COURSE released on July 09
Optimise Your Shop & Boost Sales, Effortlessly.
From overwhelmed to in-control, GYC Etsy Academy 2.0 helps you boost your Etsy sales & saves you 10+ hours every week.